Here's a comment I posted today on an article by Matthew over on http://songbytoad.com. The article is about much more than the bits I've picked out to respond to.
http://songbytoad.com/2010/02/owning-information-and-terminating-debate/#comment-41555
I help run an independent label, so I'm writing from that perspective.
We really don't have a problem with bloggers writing and sharing individual tracks on a release, as long as they use the "covermount" track we provide to everyone for free, or get permission from us to use another track. We do have a problem with bloggers posting entire albums and we file complaints against them with their hosting service provider.
We have our own semi-automated system (which I wrote myself) to deal with the actual takedown notices. It's more expensive to do things this way, but using the automatic systems the IFPI and others have developed comes at a cost in terms of the relationship artists and labels have with the fans. I think the industry organisations like the IFPI and its members the BPI and RIAA are far too heavy-handed with fans and people, like bloggers, who have less traditional roles in the music business. Educating people about the difference between what a normal independent artist earns from their music, and what a major-label-manufactured "act" makes seems like the right approach. Let's just say that almost of the artists on our label won't be quitting their day jobs any time soon.
Over the past 15 years, a new generation of music fans has developed in an environment where music is omnipresent and seemingly free. Music is not given the same value that previous generations might have attributed to it, and it is now difficult to explain how those 15 years of "free" were actually paid for by the people who produce music.
Of course there are "bloggers" who produce no original content and share entire releases, often ahead of the official release date. I don't think these bloggers are motivated by any (or much) genuine love of the music. I think their motivation is similar to that of the pirate/cracker BBS community in the computer software world--prestige and bragging rights--but these bloggers can't even claim to be particularly clever since ripping a CD is not even remotely as difficult as overcoming copy protection on software.
Leave a comment